If there was something wrong with him, or me, I couldn’t tell. We couldn’t tell, because the reality of the situation had escaped us long ago.
There were four of us that night, or two, that night at the lake, which in the winter gloom was like a smooth black mirror against the black sky, mottled with violently blinking stars and a muffled moon.
In the summer we had come here, to be all alone and together. And in the summer, here, by the lake in the daytime when it was a murky, ineffectual green, the color sludge, he told me what he wanted us to do.
It had to be us, he said, because we knew. We knew listening to someone speak and processing the speech, the words falling out of their lips and tripping over their tongues in a burbling stream of bullshit, and we knew what it was to be only half there, to be in several places at once all at the same time, and we knew what it was to look at a person (like a mother, a teacher, or a sanitation worker) and imagine with explicit detail choking them to death, or shooting them in the skull at point-blank range, a cartoon spray of blood speckling our faces as we blew their brains out.
This is what he did sometimes, he told me, to comfort himself. “I picture people that I love die.”
We knew like no one else could know or cared to know and so, really, it had to be us.
At the lake, in the relative silence of the evening I could see, refracted in the light that glinted off the cool steel handle of the knife, the tiny fragments of all our lives that had led up to this exact moment. It was an intricate mosaic of cause and effect, of action and outcome, all so deafeningly clear that it was almost disgusting.
He said nothing. I remember he held his hand up, briefly – a strange, jerky motion that we couldn’t understand and therefore did not bother to process. When the blade sliced through the thin layer of skin that had lain taut over his Adam’s apple it had been simultaneously the most glorious and most mundane thing I’d ever witnessed.
Glorious, of course, in its banality.
It was rather easy, after that. I had the strange, almost comical image of a ripe tomato in my mind as I watched the blade slice through skin and muscle, sometimes hitting bone.
“See how you’re brother’s blood cries out to me from the earth,” one of us whispered – a half remembered Bible verse.
It went on like this for some time.
We laid his body out along the lakeside. This long, useless thing. Blood, bright, the color of a dress I’d seen once at a party once, was gushing from the wound his throat in spurts, in stops and starts, as if his body hadn’t decided yet whether it wanted to die.
We sat next to him, but we didn’t touch him, or look at him, not even when he moaned something, inaudible, and reached out his hand. Acknowledging the act would have ruined integrity of the thing.
Eventually one of us said, “Is he dying? I think he's dying.”
And then, "I want to go home...I don't like it here. It's dark. I'm scared."
Another one of us laughed. I don’t know who.